Meet the Best College Admissions Team For You
Welcome to our dedicated team of college counselors, each committed to guiding students and families through every stage of the admissions journey.
Our counselors work collaboratively to provide personalized, strategic support tailored to each student’s academic profile, goals, and aspirations. With diverse backgrounds in education, admissions, counseling, and mentorship, our team helps students navigate the college process with confidence, clarity, and purpose.
Together, we strive to make the college admissions experience more manageable, less stressful, and ultimately more successful for every family we serve.
The College Counselor Dream Team
~
The College Counselor Dream Team ~
Jenna Shulman
Founder & Owner
Jenna Shulman, founder and owner of Get Me Into College, has guided students through the college admissions process since 2015, helping more than 1,500 students nationwide. As the visionary behind the firm’s personalized and strategic approach, Jenna draws on visits to more than 225 college campuses and a background in corporate writing and journalism to help students build compelling personal brands and navigate the admissions process with confidence.
Allie McMahon
College Counselor
Allie McMahon is a college counselor with over ten years of experience in public and private schools, helping students and families navigate academic planning and college preparation. She specializes in college searches and applications and has visited more than 100 college campuses.
Katie Perry
Director of College Counselors
Katie Perry serves as Director of College Counselors, overseeing our counseling team to ensure every client receives the high-quality process our company is known for. She has personally guided over 300 students through the college admissions journey and brings strategic expertise in essay development, project management, and admissions planning.
Evan Gerstein, M.Ed.
College Counselor
Evan Gerstein is an independent college counselor and former University of Michigan admissions counselor who guides students through every stage of the college admissions process. Currently pursuing his Doctor of Education at Vanderbilt University, Evan brings deep expertise in admissions strategy, college selection, and application planning.
Amy Carangelo
College Counselor
Amy Carangelo is an independent college counselor with over six years of experience as a high school counselor. With expertise in 504 and IEP programming, she provides thoughtful, personalized guidance tailored to each student’s unique goals and needs.
Alex Roberts
College Counselor
Alex Roberts is an independent college counselor with over a decade of experience in education and currently serves as a high school counselor in New Jersey. Drawing on her background in NYU Admissions and public schools, she helps students and families navigate the college process with insight, empathy, and a calm, supportive approach.
Amy Calzone
College Counselor, Essay Coach
Amy Calzone is a seasoned educator and college counselor with over 15 years of experience teaching Advanced English and AP Language. She specializes in college applications and essay development, with additional expertise supporting students pursuing the performing arts.
Karissa Handler
College Counselor, Essay Coach
Karissa Handler is an independent college counselor and New Jersey school counselor with seven years of experience supporting students in academics, career planning, and personal development. With a background in journalism, public relations, and family services, she helps students present their strongest, most authentic selves throughout the admissions process.
Nicole Eisner
College Counselor
Nicole is an experienced college counselor who provides thoughtful guidance throughout the admissions process, helping students look beyond academics to identify colleges that align with their personal interests, lifestyle preferences, and long-term goals.